Saturday, June 18, 2011

Thoughts on Wii Zelda

At the recent E3 convention, they showed a preview for Legend of Zelda: Skyward Sword.  They also had three playable demos for the game.  The demos were...well, let me back up for a moment.

The previous Zelda game is Legend of Zelda: Twilight Princess.  They had various demos for that game, at E3 2005 and E3 2006.  These demos included...

  • The goat herding minigame
  • The horseback battle with King Bulbin
  • Link's home village, especially the hawk guiding
  • The first dungeon
  • The second dungeon

The demos were great, although some of them were blatant excuses to show off the Wii's motion technology.  I'm looking at you, bow and arrow.  Also at you, hawk gliding.

In the actual game itself, the things that were shown off in the demos ended up being isolated.  You only do the goat herding challenge once in the game, twice if you want a heart piece.  You only do hawk guiding once, twice if you're observant enough to find the second piece of hawk grass on Death Mountain Trail.  The special weapon of the first dungeon gets used twice, and horseback battling occurs three times.

So really, the things that were shown off in the Twilight Princess demos were basically made just for the sake of having good demos.  They did not really come into play during the actual game itself.  Personally, I'm a little disappointed that the cool hawk guiding demo didn't get used in the game itself, whereas I'm glad they didn't have more goat herding challenges, because that was kind of bothersome.

There were three Skyward Sword demos at the recent E3. They all were in HD and ran off of the Wii U system.  The idea was to show off the Wii U's HD capabilities.  The actual Zelda game itself will not be in HD, or run off of the Wii U.  So again, these are things they made just for the purposes of having a cool demo.

Then again, the game is done in Toon Link style.  Do we really need HD Toon Link?  I can't tell the difference between HD cartoons and non-HD cartoons.

Demo #1 was a bird-flying minigame.  It's basically the same as horseback racing in the other Zelda games, where you press A to make your animal spring forward, and you have to wait for your meter to refill before you can do it again.  Do you remember the bird-flying challenge in Twilight Princess?  It's basically the exact same thing, except now you have people that you are racing.

The bird flying looked kind of boring, actually, compared to the near-identical bird races in Super Mario Galaxy 2.  In Mario's game, you had all sorts of walls and obstructions to dodge, which made it a challenge.  In the Zelda demo, it was pretty much all just open skies and clouds, with an occasional floating island in your way.  Maybe in the actual game itself, it will be a more difficult challenge.

The second demo was Forest Dungeon, which I'm guessing is Dungeon #1.  Why is the forest dungeon always first, it seems?  That was the case in Ocarina of Time, Majora's Mask and Twilight Princess.  Most of the dungeon involved using the flying beetle item.  Just like the birds from the first demo, you use the Wii-mote to control the flight path of the beetle.  Hit a wall, and you have to start over.

The person playing the demo I watched was really bad, and he kept smashing into walls.  The beetle seemed like an interesting item, but I only saw it used for one purpose: hitting switches that are high up in the air.  Let's hope it has more functionality in the actual game, or else I'm just going to use the bow and arrow instead.

The third demo was the boss battle.  This was a tech demo, basically.  It's supposed to show off how good the controls are, and how you have to be very precise with your movements. The idea is that you use your Wii-mote as an actual sword, but to be honest, it looked somewhat counter-intuitive. At this point, everyone is so used to "waggle the Wii-mote to get a reaction" that "waggle the Wii-mote in very precise directions" seemed unnecessarily challenging.

Also, it looks like you absolutely have to stand up to use these controls.  I have not played a Wii game while standing up in years.  I play the games while sitting down, because my TV is at eye level with my couch. I would like to avoid playing this game standing up, if that is at all possible.

Without having used these precise sword controls, I can't tell you if they're good or not.  It looks like they could be a pain, and it looks like they could add a level of realism to the game.  I am reminded of the sword fighting challenge in Wii Sports Resort, where the controls were super-precise and complicated, but really, the way you won the challenge was by randomly waving your arm all over the place.  So really, it could go either way at this point.

All in all, Skyward Sword looks like a decent enough game so far. The controls seem to work perfectly fine for everything, except maybe the sword fighting, where too much precision seems like too much hassle. The graphics look good, even if I'm still not sold on the Toon Link graphical style. But all complaints aside, we know for certain that Link has a flying thing which follows him around and tells him what to do. That means it's sure to be another exciting Zelda adventure.


Diana said...

Agreed. I'm not looking forward to precise controls, but if there is a flying thing, it's sure to be another exciting, ANNOYING, Zelda adventure.

Airam said...

I am kinda upset about Nintendo's choices on this game, 1. I don't like the mix of 3-D Twilght Princess graphics with the 2-D cartoony Wind Waker graphics, It looks like WOW graphics and I don't like it. 2. I am kinda sad that this is gonna be the last Zelda game for Wii, I like my Wii, and I like Zelda, I was so excited when I got my cop,y of Twilght Princess, it was a fun game over-all, I liked the challenges, the characters, the whole plot, everything. I was hoping Nintendo would make more Zelda games for Wii, but the only "new" games are Twilght Princess and Skyward Sword, they just harbored the old games. Sorry for the major rant but I hope this is a good game.

Anonymous said...

Michael i say u do a video walkthrough for Twilight Princess:D
it's an awesome game and ur commentary will make it even better ;)