Recently, I've seen several comments about Nancy Drew: Shadow at the Water's Edge that look like this:
"Awesome! I hope it's longer than Trail of the Twister! That game was SOOOO short!"
I don't remember Trail of the Twister being short, but after reading six or so complaints about it, I decided to double-check how long it is. My video walkthrough for that game is three and a half hours, so it's probably about four hours long on the first playthrough. That's not short...right?
So here's my question: How long should a game be?